| Dylan Baker | Alan | (Mar 2, 2010 - ?) |
| Jeff Daniels | Michael | (Mar 2, 2010 - ?) |
| Christine Lahti | Veronica | (Nov 17, 2009-Feb 28, 2010) |
| Lucy Liu Broadway Debut | Annette | (Mar 2, 2010 - ?) |
| Janet McTeer | Veronica | (Mar 2, 2010 - ?) |
| Annie Potts | Annette | (Nov 17, 2009-Feb 28, 2010) |
| Jimmy Smits | Alan | (Nov 17, 2009-Feb 28, 2010) |
| Ken Stott | Michael | (Nov 17, 2009-Feb 28, 2010) |