| Eric Anderson | Ensemble | (Jan 6, 2009 - ?) |
| Stewpot | (Jan 6, 2009 - ?) | |
| Ana Maria Andricain | Ensemble | |
| Ensign Connie Walewska | ||
| Michael Arnold | Ensemble | |
| Seabee Johnny Noonan | ||
| Becca Ayers | Ensign Janet MacGregor | |
| Craig Bennett | Seaman Thomas Hassinger | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Wendi Bergamini | Ensemble | |
| Ensign Janet MacGregor | ||
| Matt Caplan | Professor | (Jan 6, 2009 - ?) |
| Todd Cerveris | Ensemble | |
| Seabee Morton Wise | ||
| David Pittsinger while Paulo Szot fulfilled previously scheduled opera commitments | Emile de Becque | (Dec 2, 2008-Jan 25, 2009) |
| Emile de Becque | (Mar 12, 2009-Apr 12, 2009) | |
| Emile de Becque | ||
| Christian Delcroix | Professor | |
| Branch Fields | Petty Officer Hamilton Steves | |
| Rob Gallagher | Lieutenant Eustis Carmichael | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Murphy Guyer | Captain George Brackett, U.S.N. | |
| Deborah Lew | Bloody Mary's Assistant | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Peter Lockyer | Ensemble | |
| Radio Operator Bob McCaffrey | ||
| Liz McCartney | Ensemble | |
| Lt. Genevieve Marshall | (Jun 24, 2008 - ?) | |
| William Michals While Paulo Szot was on leave | Emile de Becque | (? - Mar 30, 2010) |
| While Paulo Szot was on leave | Emile de Becque | (Apr 13, 2010-Apr 18, 2010) |
| While Paulo Szot was on leave | Emile de Becque | (Jun 1, 2010-Jul 4, 2010) |
| Marla Mindelle | Ensemble | |
| Ensign Cora MacRae | ||
| Laura Osnes while Kelli O'Hara was on maternity leave | Ensign Nellie Forbush | (Mar 10, 2009-Oct 4, 2009) |
| Ensign Nellie Forbush | (Jan 5, 2010-Aug 8, 2010) | |
| Alfie Parker, Jr. | Ensemble | |
| Seaman Tom O'Brien | ||
| Andrew Samonsky | Lt. Joseph Cable, U.S.M.C. | (Jan 6, 2009 - ?) |
| Jason Michael Snow | Yeoman Herbert Quale | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Lucia Spina | Lt. Genevieve Marshall | (Dec 11, 2008-Jan 4, 2009) |
| Matt Wall | Ensemble | (May 19, 2009-Dec 20, 2009) |
| Seabee Morton Wise | (May 19, 2009-Dec 20, 2009) |