| Lynne Abeles | Spanish Lady | (Jul 30, 2012 - ?) |
| Emily Addona | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Dara Adler | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | ||
| Deanne Albert | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| D.C. Anderson | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Passarino | ||
| Lawrence Anderson | ||
| George Lee Andrews | Monsieur Firmin | |
| Monsieur André | ||
| Luann Aronson | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Peter Atherton | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Passarino | ||
| Michael Babin | Hairdresser | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Polly Baird | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Meg Giry | ||
| Sarah Bakker | Madame Firmin | (Apr 2013 - ?) |
| Katie Banks | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Kyle Barisich | Hairdresser | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | (Jun 6, 2011 - ?) | |
| Gary Barker | Monsieur Reyer | |
| Steve Barton | Phantom of the Opera | (Mar 19, 1990 - ?) |
| Elena Jeanne Batman | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Harlan Bengel | Solo Dancer | |
| Craig A. Benham | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Teri Bibb | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Jessica Bishop | Meg Giry | (Jul 4, 2011-Jan 14, 2012) |
| Torrance Blaisdell | Fireman | |
| Porter | ||
| Sierra Boggess | Christine Daaé | (Jan 21, 2013-Mar 2, 2013) |
| Chris Bohannon | Fireman | |
| Porter | ||
| Victoria Born | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Tener Brown | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Meg Giry | ||
| Kimilee Bryant | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Princess in "Hannibal" | ||
| Spanish Lady | ||
| Carlotta Guidicelli | Alternate | |
| Erick Buckley | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Katharine Buffaloe | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Stephen R. Buntrock | Fireman | |
| Marksman | ||
| Porter | ||
| Erin Brooke Burton | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Keith Buterbaugh | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Marilyn Caskey | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| Madame Giry | ||
| Marisa Cerveris | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Harriet Clark | Ballet Swing | |
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | ||
| David Cleveland | Marksman | |
| Porter | ||
| Patti Cohenour | Christine Daaé | |
| Courtney Combs | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Maurizio Corbino | Fireman | |
| Marksman | ||
| Porter | ||
| Cornel Crabtree | Solo Dancer | |
| Virginia Croskery | Princess in "Hannibal" | |
| David Cryer | Monsieur Firmin | |
| John Cudia | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (May 22, 2008-Jul 30, 2008) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Jul 27, 2009-Sep 4, 2010) | |
| Karen Culliver | Christine Daaé | |
| Nicholas Cunningham | Solo Dancer | (2012 - ?) |
| Slave Master in "Hannibal" | ||
| Marie Danvers | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Princess in "Hannibal" | ||
| Mary D'Arcy | Christine Daaé | |
| Marcy De Gonge-Manfredi | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Spanish Lady | ||
| Teresa DeRose | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Geralyn Del Corso | Meg Giry | |
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | ||
| Rhonda Dillon | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Andrew Drost | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Porter | ||
| Fireman | ||
| Fireman | ||
| Porter | ||
| Amanda Edge | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Rebecca Eichenberger | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Carlotta Guidicelli | ||
| Teresa Eldh | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Kelly Ellenwood | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| Susan Facer | Princess in "Hannibal" | |
| Melanie Field | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Sara Jean Ford | Christine Daaé | (Sep 7, 2010-Dec 3, 2011) |
| Davis Gaines | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Jul 4, 1994 - ?) | |
| Aaron Galligan-Stierle | Monsieur André | (Sep 5, 2011-Nov 10, 2012) |
| Paloma Garcia-Lee | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Meg Giry | (Apr 18, 2011-Apr 25, 2011) | |
| Meg Giry | Alternate (Apr 9, 2012 - ?) | |
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | ||
| David Michael Garry | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| David Gaschen | Jeweler | |
| Phantom of the Opera | ||
| Ubaldo Piangi | ||
| Ubaldo Piangi | Alternate | |
| Joelle Gates | Meg Giry | |
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | ||
| Charlene Gehm | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Leslie Giammanco | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Gary Giffune | Flunky | |
| Stagehand | ||
| Susan Gladstone | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Ballet Swing | ||
| Tim Martin Gleason | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Patty Goble | Madame Firmin | |
| Nina Goldman | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Rayanne Gonzales | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Diana Gonzalez | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Kelly Jeanne Grant | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Kevin Gray | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Dec 3, 1990 - ?) | |
| Cris Groenendaal | Phantom of the Opera | (Mar 20, 1989 - ?) |
| Kristina Marie Guiget | Madame Giry | |
| Kristina Marie Guiguet | Madame Giry | |
| Joe Gustern | Joseph Buquet | |
| Julie Hanson | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Princess in "Hannibal" | ||
| Christine Daaé | Alternate (Dec 12, 2006 - ?) | |
| Paul Harman | Firechief | |
| Monsieur Firmin | ||
| Evan Harrington | Ubaldo Piangi | (? - Aug 20, 2011) |
| Wren Marie Harrington | Spanish Lady | |
| Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Ellen Harvey | Madame Giry | (Nov 12, 2012 - ?) |
| Jack Hayes | Flunky | |
| Stagehand | ||
| Slave Master in "Hannibal" | Alternate | |
| Solo Dancer | Alternate | |
| Jessy Hendrickson | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | (Jun 4, 2012 - ?) |
| Frederic Heringes | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Ubaldo Piangi | (Sep 11, 1993-Sep 10, 1995) | |
| Ubaldo Piangi | (Sep 9, 1996-Oct 12, 1996) | |
| Ubaldo Piangi | (Sep 13, 1997-Mar 12, 1998) | |
| Alina Hernandez | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Nancy Hess | Madame Giry | |
| Arlo Hill | Passarino | (Aug 6, 2012 - ?) |
| Jeweler | ||
| Heather Hill | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | (Sep 24, 2012 - ?) |
| Samantha Hill | Christine Daaé | Alternate (Nov 12, 2012 - ?) |
| Christine Daaé | (Mar 4, 2013 - ?) | |
| Careen Hobart | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Wayne Hobbs | Ubaldo Piangi | (Jul 2007-Mar 2008) |
| Satomi Hofmann | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Confidante in "Il Muto" | ||
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Cristin J. Hubbard | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Swing | ||
| Madame Giry | (? - Nov 10, 2012) | |
| Chris Huddleston | Joseph Buquet | |
| David Huneryager | Monsieur Firmin | (May 10, 2003-May 29, 2003) |
| Patricia Hurd | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| Mary Illes | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Anita Intrieri | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Susannah Israel | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Mark Jacoby | Phantom of the Opera | (Feb 22, 1991 - ?) |
| Geena Jeffries | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| John Jellison | Fireman | (? - Nov 13, 2004) |
| Monsieur Lefèvre | (? - Nov 13, 2004) | |
| Diane Jennings | Spanish Lady | |
| Tim Jerome | Monsieur Firmin | (Nov 12, 2012 - ?) |
| Timothy Jerome | Monsieur Firmin | |
| Firechief | ||
| Monsieur Lefèvre | ||
| Peter Jöback | Phantom of the Opera | (Apr 29, 2013-Aug 24, 2013) |
| Melody Johnson | Madame Firmin | |
| Cherylyn Jones | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Patrick Jones | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Sandra Joseph | Christine Daaé | (Jan 29, 1998-Apr 15, 2006) |
| Rebecca Judd | Madame Giry | |
| Leslie Judge | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Kenneth Kantor | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Firechief | ||
| Monsieur Firmin | ||
| Monsieur Lefèvre | ||
| Raissa Katona | Princess in "Hannibal" | |
| Ted Keegan | Jeweler | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Jeff Keller | Monsieur André | |
| Monsieur Firmin | ||
| Diane Ketchie | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Spanish Lady | ||
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Kfir | Solo Dancer | |
| Solo Dancer | ||
| Dale Kirstein | Christine Daaé | |
| Kara Klein | Meg Giry | |
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | (Jan 16, 2012-Jun 17, 2012) | |
| Meg Giry | (Jun 18, 2012 - ?) | |
| Kris Koop | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Spanish Lady | ||
| Carlotta Guidicelli | Alternate | |
| Madame Firmin | ||
| Dale Kristien | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| John Kuether | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Passarino | ||
| Auctioneer | ||
| Michael Lackley | Hairdresser | |
| Gina Lamparella | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | (Aug 6, 2012 - ?) |
| Mykal D. Laury, II | Slave Master in "Hannibal" | |
| Dustin Layton | Solo Dancer | (Sep 10, 2012 - ?) |
| Aaron Lazar | Fireman | |
| Laurie LeBlance | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Ballet Swing | ||
| Wendi Lees Smart | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Michael Shawn Lewis | Marksman | |
| Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | (2001 - ?) | |
| Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | (Apr 3, 2006 - ?) | |
| Sabra Lewis | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Kevin Ligon | Monsieur Firmin | (Sep 5, 2011-Nov 10, 2012) |
| Gary Lindemann | Hairdresser | |
| Marksman | ||
| Porter | ||
| Brad Little | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Phantom of the Opera | ||
| Jennifer Little | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Spanish Lady | ||
| Peter Lockyer | Hairdresser | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Ubaldo Piangi | Alternate | |
| David Loring | Slave Master in "Hannibal" | |
| Gianna Loungway | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Marcus Lovett | Phantom of the Opera | (May 24, 1993 - ?) |
| Elizabeth Loyacano | Christine Daaé | Alternate (Dec 8, 2007 - ?) |
| Annemarie Lucania | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Rebecca Luker | Christine Daaé | |
| Christine Daaé | Alternate | |
| Natasha MacAller | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Sean MacLaughlin | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | (Dec 6, 2010 - ?) |
| John MacMaster | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Lori MacPherson | Ballet Swing | |
| Laura Martin | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Leila Martin | Madame Giry | |
| Frank Mastrone | Jeweler | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Ubaldo Piangi | Alternate | |
| Gary Mauer | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| During Howard McGillin's vacation | Phantom of the Opera | (Apr 30, 2007-May 19, 2007) |
| Liz McCartney | Carlotta Guidicelli | (Mar 19, 1999-Apr 21, 2001) |
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | (Mar 19, 1999-Apr 21, 2001) | |
| Spanish Lady | (Mar 19, 1999-Apr 21, 2001) | |
| Carlotta Guidicelli | (Dec 6, 2010 - ?) | |
| Michele McConnell | Carlotta Guidicelli | (Jul 11, 2011 - ?) |
| Adrienne McEwen | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Heather McFadden | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Meg Giry | ||
| Meg Giry | (Jan 16, 2012-Jun 17, 2012) | |
| Howard McGillin | Phantom of the Opera | (Aug 23, 1999-Apr 12, 2003) |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Dec 22, 2003-Jan 4, 2004) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Jun 26, 2004-Jul 3, 2004) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Jul 30, 2008-Jul 25, 2009) | |
| Scott Mikita | Auctioneer | |
| Fireman | ||
| Marksman | ||
| Passarino | ||
| Porter | ||
| Greg Mills | Monsieur Reyer | |
| Jason Mills | Auctioneer | |
| Passarino | ||
| Mabel Modrono | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Trista Moldovan | Christine Daaé | (Dec 9, 2011-Nov 10, 2012) |
| Larry Wayne Morbitt | Ubaldo Piangi | (? - Mar 29, 2006) |
| Aubrey Morgan | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Nathan Patrick Morgan | Jeweler | (Jul 30, 2012 - ?) |
| Leigh Munro | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| John Horton Murray | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Elizabeth Nackley | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Timothy Nolen | Phantom of the Opera | (Oct 10, 1988 - ?) |
| Thomas James O'Leary | Phantom of the Opera | (Oct 11, 1996 - ?) |
| Monsieur Reyer | (Oct 11, 1996 - ?) | |
| Eric Otte | Slave Master in "Hannibal" | |
| Susan Owen | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Princess in "Hannibal" | ||
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| Madame Firmin | (Sep 2012 - ?) | |
| Geoff Packard | Hairdresser | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | Alternate | |
| Hugh Panaro | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | (Jan 1991-May 1992) |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Feb 1, 1999 - ?) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Apr 14, 2003-Dec 21, 2003) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Jan 5, 2004-Jun 25, 2004) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Jul 4, 2004 - ?) | |
| Phantom of the Opera | (Sep 7, 2010 - ?) | |
| Shaun R. Parry | Solo Dancer | |
| Justin Peck | Solo Dancer | |
| Slave Master in "Hannibal" | ||
| Sarah Pfisterer | Christine Daaé | |
| Tania Philip | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Patricia Phillips | Carlotta Guidicelli | |
| Confidante in "Il Muto" | ||
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Patrice Pickering | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Rebecca Pitcher | Princess in "Hannibal" | |
| Christine Daaé | Alternate (Jul 2005-Apr 15, 2006) | |
| Christine Daaé | (Apr 17, 2006 - ?) | |
| Richard Poole | Hairdresser | |
| Joseph Buquet | ||
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Monsieur André | Alternate | |
| Richard Warren Pugh | Joseph Buquet | |
| Alba Quezada | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Marni Raab | Christine Daaé | (Aug 20, 2008 - ?) |
| Christine Daaé | Alternate | |
| Christine Daaé | (Nov 13, 2012 - ?) | |
| Christine Daaé | Alternate (Mar 4, 2013 - ?) | |
| Jessica Radetsky | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Gregory Emanuel Rahming | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Gary Rideout | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| Rebecca Robbins | Confidante in "Il Muto" | (Sep 3, 2012 - ?) |
| Wardrobe Mistress | (Sep 3, 2012 - ?) | |
| Stacey Robinson | Policeman | |
| Wesley Robinson | Flunky | |
| Slave Master in "Hannibal" | ||
| Stagehand | ||
| James Romick | Firechief | |
| Monsieur Lefèvre | ||
| Phantom of the Opera | ||
| Fred Rose | Marksman | |
| Melody Rubie | Madame Firmin | |
| Anne Runolfsson | Carlotta Guidicelli | (Nov 16, 2004 - ?) |
| Roland Rusinek | Ubaldo Piangi | (Mar 31, 2006 - ?) |
| Susan Russell | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Daniel Rychlec | Slave Master in "Hannibal" | Alternate |
| Solo Dancer | Alternate | |
| Paul B. Sadler Jr. | Solo Dancer | |
| Slave Master in "Hannibal" | ||
| Janet Saia | Confidante in "Il Muto" | |
| Wardrobe Mistress | ||
| Kristie Dale Sanders | Madame Giry | (Jan 2008-Nov 2010) |
| Thomas Sandri | Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | |
| Passarino | ||
| Policeman | ||
| Nicolas F. Saverine | Ubaldo Piangi | |
| David A. Scamardo | Slave Master in "Hannibal" | |
| Solo Dancer | ||
| Paul A. Schaefer | Marksman | |
| Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | Alternate | |
| Marksman | ||
| Julie Schmidt | Carlotta Guidicelli | (? - Nov 13, 2004) |
| Confidante in "Il Muto" | (? - Nov 13, 2004) | |
| Wardrobe Mistress | (? - Nov 13, 2004) | |
| Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | ||
| John Schroeder | Marksman | |
| Christian Šebek | Ubaldo Piangi | (Sep 2, 2011 - ?) |
| Carly Blake Sebouhian | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Meg Giry | ||
| Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | ||
| Tracy Shayne | Christine Daaé | |
| Ciarán Sheehan | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Jeff Siebert | Flunky | |
| Stagehand | ||
| Ryan Silverman | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | (Apr 24, 2009 - ?) |
| Kitty Skillman Hilsabeck | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Jimmy Smagula | Fireman | |
| Porter | ||
| Kate Solmssen | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Elizabeth Southard | Christine Daaé | |
| Princess in "Hannibal" | ||
| Christine Spizzo | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Dana Stackpole | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Megan Starr-Levitt | Princess in "Hannibal" | |
| Lorian Stein | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | (Feb 1990-Jul 1990) |
| Laurie Gayle Stephenson | Christine Daaé | Alternate |
| Christine Daaé | ||
| Jeremy Stolle | Passarino | |
| Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | Alternate | |
| Dawn Leigh Stone | Madame Firmin | |
| Thomas Terry | Flunky | |
| Solo Dancer | ||
| Stephen Tewksbury | Fireman | |
| Porter | ||
| Joseph Buquet | Alternate | |
| Richard Toda | Solo Dancer | |
| John J. Todd | Slave Master in "Hannibal" | |
| Joan Tsao | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| Catherine Ulissey | Meg Giry | |
| Carrington Vilmont | Hairdresser | |
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Passarino | ||
| Broadway debut | Auctioneer | |
| Broadway debut | Marksman | |
| Auctioneer | ||
| Don Attilio in "Il Muto" | ||
| Lisa Vroman | Christine Daaé | |
| Dianna Warren | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| John Wasiniak | Fireman | |
| Porter | ||
| Ubaldo Piangi | Alternate | |
| Scott Watanabe | Passarino | |
| Policeman | ||
| Jim Weitzer | Raoul Vicomte de Chagny | |
| Hairdresser | ||
| Monsieur Reyer | ||
| Monsieur André | (Nov 12, 2012 - ?) | |
| Elizabeth Welch | Princess in "Hannibal" | |
| Sharon Wheatley | Page in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Sally Williams | Madame Giry | |
| Spanish Lady | ||
| Jennifer Hope Wills | Christine Daaé | Alternate (Apr 20, 2006 - ?) |
| Christine Daaé | (Dec 12, 2006-Aug 16, 2008) | |
| Christine Daaé | (? - Sep 4, 2010) | |
| Bruce Winant | Monsieur Firmin | |
| Johanna Wiseman | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | |
| Wysandria Woolsey | Innkeeper's Wife in "Don Juan Triumphant" | (Sep 1989-Feb 1990) |
| Katherine Wray | Ballet Chorus of the Opéra Populaire | |
| James Zander | Flunky |