| Brooks Ashmanskas | Bud Frump | |
| John Bolton | Ensemble | |
| J. Pierrepont Finch | ||
| Office Boy | ||
| Ovington | ||
| TV Announcer | ||
| Tracy Nicole Chapman | Scrubwoman | |
| Tina Fabrique | Miss Jones | |
| Tom Flagg | Office Boy | |
| Ovington | ||
| TV Announcer | ||
| Lisa Gajda | Ensemble | |
| Wickette | ||
| Christopher Gattelli | Henchman | |
| Gordon Greenberg | Ensemble | |
| Tackaberry | ||
| JoAnn M. Hunter | Ensemble | |
| Adriane Lenox | Miss Jones | |
| Kristi Lynes | Rosemary Pillkington | |
| John MacInnis | ||
| Susan Misner | Dance Soloist | |
| Martin Moran During Matthew Broderick's vacation | J. Pierrepont Finch | |
| Michelle O'Steen | Dance Soloist | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Wickette | ||
| Sarah Jessica Parker | Rosemary Pillkington | |
| Stephen Reed | Ensemble | (Mar 27, 1996-May 19, 1996) |
| William Ryall | J.B. Biggley | |
| John Stamos | J. Pierrepont Finch | |
| Jessica Stone | Rosemary Pillkington |