| Christopher Allen | Apostle | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Seth Allen | Pontius Pilate | (Jan 24, 1972 - ?) |
| Roy Bailey | Apostle | |
| Leper | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Edward Q. Bhartonn | Judas' Tormentor | |
| Soldier | ||
| Alan Blair | Judas' Tormentor | |
| Soldier | ||
| Penelope Bodry | Cured Leper | |
| Temple Lady | ||
| Gail Boggs | Singer | |
| Soul Girl | ||
| Robert Brandon | Leper | |
| Merchant | ||
| Peter | ||
| Dennis Cooley | Jesus of Nazareth | |
| Martha Deering | Apostle Woman | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Temple Lady | ||
| Kathye Dezina Broadway debut | Mary Magdalene | |
| W.P. Dremak | Pontius Pilate | |
| Carol Estey | Leper | |
| Reporter | ||
| Temple Lady | ||
| Greg Evigan | Apostle | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Merchant | ||
| Tormentor (Judas' Death) | ||
| Realinda Farrell | Singer | |
| Soul Girl | ||
| Lorraine Feather | Apostle Woman | |
| Leper | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Temple Lady | ||
| Lynn Gerb | Apostle Woman | |
| Leper | ||
| Reporter | ||
| William Gestrich | Apostle | |
| Dan Gibson | Leper | |
| Merchant | ||
| Singer | ||
| DeMarest Grey | Apostle | |
| William Daniel Grey | Annas | |
| Marta Heflin | Mary Magdalene | (Apr 17, 1972 - ?) |
| Spence Henderson | Judas' Tormentor | |
| Soldier | ||
| Jeffrey Hillock | First Priest | |
| Patrick Hude | Judas Iscariot | |
| Patrick Jude | Judas Iscariot | |
| Stephen Klein | Caiaphas | |
| Michael Lamont | Apostle | |
| Leper | ||
| Merchant | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Tormentor (Judas' Death) | ||
| Roger Lawson | Second Priest | |
| Cliff Lipson | Judas' Tormentor | |
| Soldier | ||
| Doug Lucas | Old Man | |
| Reggie Mack | Leper | |
| Merchant | ||
| Simon Zealotes | ||
| George Mansour Broadway debut | Pontius Pilate | |
| William Parry | Third Priest | |
| Shezwae Powell | Singer | |
| Soul Girl | ||
| Christina Putnam | Apostle Woman | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Temple Lady | ||
| Curt Ralston | Leper | |
| Merchant | ||
| Singer | ||
| Linda Ribbach | Apostle Woman | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Temple Lady | ||
| Vicki Sue Robinson | Leper | |
| Reporter | ||
| Singer | ||
| James Sbano | Judas' Tormentor | |
| Soldier | ||
| Mark Shannon | Apostle | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Merchant | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Tormentor (Judas' Death) | ||
| Dennis Simpson | Apostle | |
| Leper | ||
| Merchant | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Judas' Tormentor | ||
| Soldier | ||
| Jack Starkey | Apostle | |
| Singer | ||
| Shirley Sypert | Apostle Woman | |
| Singer | ||
| Soul Girl | ||
| Victor Vail | Apostle | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Reporter | ||
| Margaret Warncke | Maid by the Fire | |
| Randy Wilson | Apostle | |
| Cured Leper | ||
| Merchant |