| Philip Coolidge | Deputy-Governor Danforth | |
| Nell Harrison | Rebecca Nurse | |
| Cloris Leachman | Abigail Williams | |
| Donald Marye | Judge Hawthorne | |
| Claudia McNeil | ||
| Leonard Patrick | Hopkins | |
| Judy Ratner | Betty Parris | |
| Madeleine Sherwood | Mercy Lewis | |
| Maureen Stapleton | Elizabeth Proctor | |
| Harry Young | Reverend Samuel Parris |