| Barbara Barlow | Ensemble | |
| Mary | ||
| Art Barnett | Charlie Davenport | |
| Jack Beaber | Iron Tail | |
| Wild Horse Ceremonial Dancer | ||
| Warren Berlinger | Little Boy | |
| Wes Bowman | Cowboy | |
| Ensemble | ||
| John | ||
| Mr. Clay | ||
| Marlene Cameron | Minnie Annie's Sister | |
| Tessie Carrano | Ensemble | |
| Pete Civello | Cowboy | |
| Timothy Gardner | ||
| Lloyd Cole | Foster Wilson | |
| Mr. Ernest Henderson | ||
| Joseph Cunneff | Andy Turner | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Mr. Schuyler Adams | ||
| Camilla De Witt | Minnie Annie's Sister | |
| Sandra Deel | Winnie Tate | |
| Madeleine Detry | Ensemble | |
| Girl in White | ||
| Pat Dexter | Ensemble | |
| Girl in Pink | ||
| Charles Dickson | Ensemble | |
| Robert Dixon | Ensemble | |
| Harry | ||
| Andrea Downing | Cowgirl | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Girl in White | ||
| Jane Earle | Little Girl | |
| Rose Marie Elliott | Ensemble | |
| Mrs. Ernest Henderson | ||
| Bert Freed | Chief Sitting Bull | |
| Gerald Fries | Ensemble | |
| Cyprienne Gableman | Cowgirl | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Barbara Gage | Girl With Bouquet | |
| Barbara Gaye | Ensemble | |
| Girl With Bouquet | ||
| Evelyn Giles | Cowgirl | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Mary Ellen Glass | Jessie Annie's Sister | |
| Minnie Annie's Sister | ||
| Gloria Gordon | Cowgirl | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Harold Gordon | Mac Property Man | |
| Noel Gordon | Clyde Smith | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Gilbert Green | Mac Property Man | |
| Bernard Griffin | Ensemble | |
| Clarence Hall | Ensemble | |
| Freddie | ||
| Harry | ||
| Henry Hamilton | Ensemble | |
| Betty Lou Holland | Winnie Tate | |
| Eddie Howland | Ensemble | |
| Ray Hyson | John | |
| Jack Konzal | Cowboy | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Martin Kraft | Ensemble | |
| Don Liberto | Ensemble | |
| Christina Lind | Ensemble | |
| Mrs. Schyler Adams | ||
| Girl in Pink | ||
| Paula Lloyd Broadway debut | Ensemble | |
| Roslynd Lowe | Mabel | |
| Michael Maule | Ensemble | |
| Phil McEneny | Coolie | |
| Ruth Mitchell | Cowgirl | |
| Kam Moran | Nellie Annie's Sister | |
| Robert Nash | Cowboy | |
| Fernand Nault | Ensemble | |
| James Newill | Pawnee's Messenger | |
| Doreen Oswald | Ensemble | |
| Ralph Patterson | Clyde Smith | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Jack Pierce | Ensemble | |
| Timothy Gardner | ||
| Fred Rivett | Yellow Foot | |
| Beverly Sales | Jessie Annie's Sister | |
| Bernice Saunders | Nancy | |
| Claire Saunders | Girl in Pink | |
| William Skipper | Tommy Keeler | |
| Jean Spelvin | Ensemble | |
| Mary | ||
| Clifford Tatum, Jr. | Little Jake Annie's Brother | |
| Frances Taylor | Jessie Annie's Sister | |
| Rob Taylor | Ensemble | |
| Susan Taylor | Little Girl | |
| Arthur Ulisse | Cowboy | |
| Dr. Percy Ferguson | ||
| Ensemble | ||
| Katrina Van Oss | Ensemble | |
| Milton Watson | Pawnee's Messenger | |
| Frank Butler | ||
| Jean Weeks | Ensemble | |
| Elaine Baker Welch | Sylvia Potter-Porter | |
| William Weslow | Iron Tail | |
| Wild Horse Ceremonial Dancer | ||
| Gordon West | Cowboy | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Helene Whitney | Mary | |
| Parker Wilson | Ensemble | |
| Stanley Zompakos | Ensemble |