| Alexander Clark | Ninian Edwards | |
| John Corington | Ensemble | |
| Augusta Dabney | The Edwards' Maid | |
| Thomas Daly | Ensemble | |
| Edward Downes | Kavanaugh | |
| Robert Fitzsimmons | Feargus | |
| Peter Flint | Ensemble | |
| Richard Gaines | Abe Lincoln | |
| Fred Herrick | Seth Gale | |
| Wardell Jennings | Jasp | |
| Ted Kral | Ensemble | |
| Louis Marsh | Ensemble | |
| Mary Michael | Nancy Green | |
| James Moore | Sturveson | |
| Paul Nevens | Robert Lincoln | |
| William Norton | Ben Mattling | |
| Robert Porterfield | Jack Armstrong | |
| Grandon Rhodes | Joshua Speed | |
| Marion Rooney | Nancy Green | |
| Joanna Roos | Mary Todd | |
| Richard Ross | Ensemble | |
| Lewis L. Russell | Judge Bowling Green | |
| Margaret Stallings | Ensemble | |
| Anne Stevenson | The Lincolns' Maid | |
| David Stevenson | Ensemble | |
| Conway Washburn | Jed | |
| Trum Cogdal | ||
| Iris Whitney | Aggie Gale | |
| The Edwards' Maid | ||
| Jesse Wynne | Ensemble |