| ACT 1 | Sung By |
|---|
| Prelude: Onstage at the Paradise Club | Billy Lyles, Dolly Greene and Ensemble |
| New York Serenade | Dolly Greene and Female Ensemble |
| When Our Little Ship Comes Sailing In | The Duke, "Shorty" McGee and Male Ensemble |
| Dear Little Girl | Jimmy Winter and "Shorty" McGee |
| Maybe | Jimmy Winter and Kay |
| You Got What Gets Me | Billy Lyles and Dolly Greene |
| Do, Do, Do | Jimmy Winter, Kay and Janson |
| Clap Yo' Hands | Larry Potter and Ensemble |
| Someone to Watch Over Me | Kay |
| ACT 2 | Sung By |
|---|
| Oh, Kay! | Billy Lyles, Kay Jones and Ensemble |
| Ask Me Again | Jimmy Winter |
| Fidgety Feet | The Duke and Ensemble |
| Someone to Watch Over Me (Reprise) | Jimmy Winter |
| Somehow It Seldom Comes True | "Shorty" McGee |
| Where's the Boy? Where's the Girl? | Kay |
| Heaven on Earth | Larry Potter, The Duke and Billy Lyles |
| Show Me the Town | Kay, Billy Lyles, Dolly Greene, Larry Potter, The Duke and Ensemble |
| Someone to Watch Over Me (Reprise) | Jimmy Winter and Kay |
