| ACT 1 | Sung By |
| In the Very Next Moment | Maggie Cutler, Daisy Stanley, John, Sarah and Ensemble |
| Why Does the Whole Damn World Adore Me? | Sheridan Whiteside |
| Maggie's Date | Maggie Cutler, Bert Jefferson and Ensemble |
| Maybe It's Time for Me | Maggie Cutler |
| How Can You Kiss Those Good Times Goodbye | Sheridan Whiteside and Maggie Cutler |
| With This Ring | Maggie Cutler, Bert Jefferson and Sheridan Whiteside |
| Sherry | Lorraine Sheldon and Sheridan Whiteside |
| Au Revoir | Beverly Carlton |
| Proposal Duet | Lorraine Sheldon and Beverly Carlton |
| Listen Cosette | Lorraine Sheldon and Cosette |
| Christmas Eve Broadcast | Sheridan Whiteside, Lorraine Sheldon and Ensemble |
| ACT 2 | Sung By |
| Putty in Your Hands | Lorraine Sheldon and Ensemble |
| Imagine That | Maggie Cutler and Sheridan Whiteside |
| Marry the Girl Myself | Sheridan Whiteside, Maggie Cutler, Banjo, Ginger and Ensemble |
| Putty in Your Hands (Reprise) | Lorraine Sheldon, Sheridan Whiteside and Banjo |
| Harriet Sedley | Sheridan Whiteside, Banjo and Ernest W. Stanley |
| Sherry (Reprise) | Company |