| ACT 1 | Sung By |
| In the Back of a Hack | James Aloysius McCarthy and Dancers |
| Anything Can Happen | Full Company |
| So Near and Yet So Far | Mary Brooks and John Bowers |
| Don't Forget to Dream | James Aloysius McCarthy |
| Bench in the Park | Lieut. Sullivan, Officer Jonesy, Sailor, Punchy and Dancing Ensemble |
| The Letter | James Aloysius McCarthy and Friday |
| Push a Button in a Hutton | H.H. Hutton, Dancer and Singing and Dancing Ensemble |
| Home Is Where the Heart Is | Mary Brooks, John Bowers and Singing Ensemble |
| Apple Jack | Lieut. Sullivan, Sailor with Trumpet, Officer Jonesy, Friday and Singing and Dancing Ensemble |
| Wedding in the Park | James Aloysius McCarthy, Mary Brooks and John Bowers |
| Heaven on Earth | Mary Brooks, John Bowers and The Lovers |
| ACT 2 | Sung By |
| What's the Matter with Our City? | James Aloysius McCarthy and Full Company |
| So Near and Yet So Far (Reprise) | Mary Brooks and John Bowers |
| (You're the) First Cup of Coffee in the Morning | Lieut. Sullivan, Officer Clabber, Officer Jonesy, Sailor, Sailor with Trumpet and Singing and Dancing Ensemble |