| ACT 1 | Sung By |
| Heroes in the Fall | Second Robin Hood and Squad |
| Tempt Me Not | Manuelito, Clint Kelley, First Co-Ed, Second Co-Ed, Third Co-Ed, Fourth Co-Ed, Fifth Co-Ed and Sixth Co-Ed |
| My Prince | Consuelo Casey |
| Pottawattamie | Harvey Casey and Mr. Lister |
| Pottawattamie (Reprise) | Male Quartette and Ensemble |
| 'Cause We Got Cake | Eileen Eilers |
| Love Never Went to College | Consuelo Casey and Clint Kelley |
| Spic and Spanish | Pepe |
| I Like to Recognize the Tune | Jojo Jordan, Consuelo Casey, Eileen Eilers, Clint Kelley and Al Terwillinger |
| Look Out | Eileen Eilers and Company |
| ACT 2 | Sung By |
| The Sweethearts of the Team | Eileen Eilers and Co-Eds |
| She Could Shake the Maracas | Pepe and Manuelito |
| I Didn't Know What Time It Was | Consuelo Casey and Clint Kelley |
| Spic and Spanish (Reprise) | Pepe, Consuelo Casey, Eileen Eilers, Al Terwillinger, Clint Kelley, Jojo Jordan, Manuelito and Talullah Lou |
| Too Many Girls | Manuelito |
| Give It Back to the Indians | Eileen Eilers |