| 2013 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Actor in a Play |
|---|
| | Reed Birney (for "Uncle Vanya") [nominee] |
| 2011 Drama Desk Award Special Award |
|---|
 | Reed Birney (for his versatile and finely nuanced performances over the past thirty-five years, and for his exceptional work this season in "Tigers Be Still," "A Small Fire," and "The Dream of the Burning Boy") [winner] |
| 2010 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Ensemble Performance |
|---|
| Reed Birney (for "Circle Mirror Transformation") [winner] |
| 2009 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Actor in a Play |
|---|
| | Reed Birney (for "Blasted") [nominee] |
