| 2010 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | York Theatre Company (James Morgan: Artistic Director; W. David McCoy: Chairman) (for "Yank!") [nominee] |
| 2006 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | York Theatre Company (James Morgan: Artistic Director; W. David McCoy: Chairman) (for "Thrill Me") [nominee] |
| 2006 Drama Desk Award Special Award |
|---|
 | York Theatre Company (James Morgan: Artistic Director; W. David McCoy: Chairman) (for its vital contributions to theater by developing and presenting new musicals) [winner] |
| 2004 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Musical |
|---|
| | York Theatre Company (James Morgan: Artistic Director; W. David McCoy: Chairman) (for "The Musical of Musicals--The Musical") [nominee] |
